I suppose it's necessary to define "revival." Here's the one I have always preferred: "Revival is a sovereign move of God's Spirit that results in permanent change in the church." Individuals, local churches, and even regions, experience "revival" from time to time. Worldwide, Body of Christ transforming revivals only happen once in a generation.
After posting that reminder, along with the suggestion that it might be time for us to begin interceding for the next generational visitation, a friend of mine in Portland reminded me that revivals can be messy. Here is what he wrote:
"While we desperately need the holy spirit moving in our midst, as someone in their late teens during this 'outpouring' 20 years ago, there was as much damage and confusion during this season too. No public discernment from leadership, if it was weird it seemed to have the approval and the more bizarre was apparently more anointed. So many in my generation have shut the door and are closed off to the holy spirit moving because of no strong voices of discernment in Portland. I know people who were genuinely touched and ministered to by the spirit, but I know even more who left confused and disillusioned even walking away from the church."
Since I was there, participating in providing pastoral leadership during the revival, it seems important that I communicate the questions and struggles we experienced during that time. I remember asking us: When is some kind of spiritual experience the result of the activity of the Holy Spirit, a human learned (or stimulated response), or a combination of both? If most experiences are in fact both Spirit and spirit, when do they become genuinely distracting if not problematic? Is it possible to be so careful about nothing being "in the flesh" that we quench the Spirit? The bigger questions for me were: If someone has a unique experience with the Spirit, what does it mean? Why did that happen? Was it just charismatic entertainment for bored Christians? And even more importantly, if the church is experiencing a generational visitation of God's Spirit, how might the church be permanently changed as a result? What differences should we be able to observe on the other side of the "wave"?
Since I taught "Church History" at Portland Bible College at the time my referents were historical revivals. I was especially helped by the writings of Jonathan Edwards. Edwards was a prominent pastoral leader in what became known as the Great Awakening (1734-1739), a revival so powerful in its effect it changed not only Body of Christ worldwide but also the American colonies. During those years Edwards thought long and hard about the true nature and purpose of revival. He published "The Distinguishing Marks of a Work of the Holy Spirit" in 1741, in which he discussed "the bodily effects" of an unusual move the Spirit. In fact, the "swoonings, outcries and convulsions" described by Edwards were a common phenomena of all such visitations, in Edwards past and in all future revivals. It was simply true (and easily understood) that the Holy Spirit could move on someone in a way that might overpower the human emotions and body. However, they were incidental and not the marks of revival.
But at the end of that period some of those who had participated in the revival spun off into bizarre conclusions and practices. Some had concluded that these "bodily effects" were to be permanent experiences in the church, others that they were a mark of salvation, that if you didn't periodically swoon, you were either "hard to receive" or perhaps not among the elect at all. Some began to practice "free love" and form new, unorthodox sectarian groups. As a result, in 1746, Edwards published his famous work, "Religious Affections," in which he taught that the permanent result of revival was to be the rule of God's love, pure and holy, in every part of life, individually and corporately.
So while we pray for revival, it is essential that we pray for discernment. But even importantly, that we pray for the grace to embrace all the ways in which God needs to transform his Kingdom community. There is no question that the church, including the American church, needs revival. And we are desperate to see a new generation have their own encounter with the Living God. Will it be messy? Probably. But if we keep focused on the work of the Holy Spirit among us, measured by the truth of God's Word, accessing wisdom from past revivals, I believe we will be able to receive the grace God has for us and move forward into God's preferred future for his people.